New World: Pinot Noir, USA & Canada
2017 Gold: 2 Silver: 4 Bronze: 4 Commended: 2
2016 Gold: 3 Silver: 4 Bronze: 0 Commended: 4
When teams spend most of their time debating value for money in the Sommelier Wine Awards, usually it’s a good thing: it means that the quality is solid, so the only issue is price.
Such was the case with these North American Pinots. While you wouldn’t be looking here for cheap wines (though we did have a couple of medals under £10), our tasters liked what was put before them. True, the styles are different to Burgundy, say, but the winemaking was good and they had character. And having grown from almost nothing a few years ago, this is a section of SWA that’s worth watching.
FROM THE TASTING TEAMS
‘Very exciting, very positive, lots of good wines. Some of them carry a price, but that’s normal. Overall very pleasant, generous, positive flight. Some more traditional some more Burgundian. And the bar was quite high.’ Andrea Briccarello, team leader
‘It was difficult to find a pattern or identity in the wines. Either they were going leaner, tighter and fresher or going with ripeness and power.’ Charlie Young, Vinoteca
‘This is an important category – really good if I compare to the past five years. Now we see a more Burgundian style in the USA that I really like.’ Lionel Periner, team leader
‘We debated a lot about value and prices, but most of us were happy with most of the wines in this flight. We selected a couple for Gold that were really good value and would stand against classic Burgundies.’ Jacopo Mazzeo, The Pig Hotel at Brockenhurst