New World: Shiraz/Syrah, Grenache, Mourvedre & Rhône Blends, Rest of the New World including Argentina, Chile, New Zealand & US
2017 Gold: 3 Silver: 4 Bronze: 6 Commended: 10
2016 Gold: 1 Silver: 5 Bronze: 6 Commended: 8
Outside the Cape and Australia, if it’s Shiraz/Syrah you’re looking for, on this evidence you should probably look to Chile if you’re on a budget and New Zealand if you’re feeling flush.
If its Bordeaux blends are rather stagnating, Chile’s progress with Syrah has been impressive – and mysteriously under the radar. From nothing at all five years ago, it regularly accrues a decent raft of medals here now, and at a decent range of price points, too; established quality names like Errazuriz’s Don Max (Gold last year, Silver this) backed up with a growing number of new arrivals. There’s really no arguing with the Luis Felipe Edwards at sub £11
New Zealand blows very hot and cold here – the variety’s marginality makes it heavily vintage dependent in chilly NZ, even in Hawkes Bay. 2013, though, was a superb year, as the Man O’ War so ably demonstrates.
FROM THE TASTING TEAMS
‘The Chilean wines showed a lot of extraction, quite jammy. Easy-drinking pub-style wines. Appealing but not a lot of elegance.’ Jade Koch, team leader
‘As I expected, New Zealand performed best with New World Syrah.’ Andre Luis Martins, Cavalry & Guards Club
‘You can see the shift in style [in Chile] over the last two or three years: toning down the oak, with more freshness, more acidity, more fruit.’ Matthieu Longuère MS, Le Cordon Bleu London
‘Syrah is a grape that can do well in the New World – but I think some of these American versions were planted in the wrong place. The variety needs cooler sites.’ Annette Scarfe MW, team leader
‘I’d like to like [Chilean Syrahs] but they’re overworked and overdone, difficult to enjoy. When you have big Rhône Valley varieties, you don’t need to over extract or go overripe. Some were like drinking a Bloody Mary. Go slow with the oak and extraction, let the grape talk.’ Andrea Briccarello, team leader
‘Argentina isn’t really showing its potential with this variety.’ Andre Luis Martins, Cavalry & Guards Club
‘Too much oak, too much over extracting. Consumers seem to really enjoy [Chilean wines], but the professional palate is moving away from them.’ Stefan Kobald, Jason Atherton Group