France: South & South-West, including Savoie - Red
2018 Gold 2 Silver 8 Bronze 8 Commended 12
2017 Gold 4 Silver 9 Bronze 7 Commended 11
The one thing you want from wines from this part of France is value for money. Yes, you want ripe fruit and a little Mediterranean exuberance as well, of course you do. But if it’s on a list at £70, who’s going to buy it?
It was a problem that our tasters wrestled with throughout the judging. The cheap wines were decent, rather than ‘must-list good’, while the good wines mostly didn’t come in at a price to make them an easy sell. It’s the sommelier’s equivalent of the chicken and the egg…
By way of breaking the infinite circle, we would like to offer special congratulations to Château Maris, for following up its white Gold with a red here as well.
FROM THE TASTING TEAMS
‘I was really impressed by the character and warmth of the wines here – a nice range of prices and some really exceptional quality across those price points. They’re wines of a style, with that typical sunshine of southwest France really standing out.’ Piers Gibson-Birch, Wernher Restaurant at Luton Hoo Hotel Golf & Spa
‘It was a good balance between good value and top-shelf wines. Some you might struggle to sell at the full GP but still worth it – a challenge!’ Mattia Mazzi, Lutyens Bar & Restaurants
‘I didn’t get as excited as I hoped I would. There were some very heavy bottles – I hoped we’d gotten over that by now. Even at under £8 – it just seems a bit silly.’ Jade Koch, team leader
‘Low quality at the low price levels. In the middle-to-high price bracket they were more integrated with more complexity.’ Gabriele Galuppo, Theo Randall at the InterContinental
‘Some of the entry-level ones were big and extracted but there was a bit more balance once we were over £10.’ Yohann Pinol, Wiltons