France: South & South-West – White
2019 GOLD: 3 SILVER: 6 BRONZE: 4 COMMENDED: 7
2018 GOLD: 6 SILVER: 5 BRONZE: 4 COMMENDED: 8
Going through our teams’ comments on these wines was like reading the start of A Tale of Two Cities. It was the best of flights, it was the worst of flights; it was exciting, it was boring; it was full of useful wines, it was wines that you probably can’t sell… Polarising barely covers it.
In terms of sheer numbers of medals, this was the category’s worst performance since 2015, which is disappointing. On the plus side, once the bad entries had been weeded out (and there were plenty of those) there was no shortage of decent wines (across all colours of medal) under £8, which is a real rarity this year.
FROM THE TASTING TEAMS
‘If you’re not a French restaurant I don’t think these have potential to generate big volumes, but they are food friendly.’ Olivier Gasselin, Hakkasan
‘These were fantastic, and great value for money. There was a good array here, all the way from the cheapest, which seriously overdelivered. These are very useful for UK lists, and it would probably be a shock to some, getting that much flavour at those prices.’ Michael Harrison, CuVée VIII
‘This was a very exciting flight – one of the best flights of the day. They were all so different, but all had a sense of place. They would appeal to almost all palates, and texture-wise were very food friendly, too.’ Melania Bellesini, The Fat Duck
‘A bit flabby, a lot of bitterness, nothing memorable.’ Clément Loubeyre, The Cross Kenilworth
‘There were a couple of standouts for me here, and they would all be under £40 on the list. At the lower mid-range there were lots of good options.’ Jim Bass, Scarlet Hotel
‘They had acidity and freshness, but no length or depth.’ Michael Fiducia, The Royal Automobile Club Club
‘The flight was really poor on personality. Most I would have a glass, but I wouldn’t reorder.’ Lionel Periner, team leader