Italy: Tuscany, including Montalcino & Montepulciano DOCG
2019 GOLD: 6 SILVER: 9 BRONZE: 7 COMMENDED: 19
2018 GOLD: 4 SILVER: 11 BRONZE: 8 COMMENDED: 8
We did it. We actually did it! This year saw our first sub-£10 medals in this section since 2016. Azienda Uggiano and Val delle Rose we salute you! Let there be a banging of gongs and clashing of cymbals…
That wines at this level are such a rarity tells you everything that you need to know about pricing in this part of Italy. Ambitious barely begins to cover it.
On the plus side, when they get it right, these wines are very, very good. Criticism (and there wasn’t much of it) seemed to centre on the most expensive wines, where the oak was often somewhat out of whack with the fruit. But around the £20 mark there were some fine Tuscans, with fruit, balance and typicity. They weren’t just big and blingy, they were elegant, complex and characterful.
Our teams could probably have awarded more Golds, so take a look at those Silvers.
FROM THE TASTING TEAMS
‘The Tuscan flight were not overworked, not overripe, but had a real stamp of Tuscan typicity: ripe enough fruit but also freshness and a lovely savoury core.’ Martin Lam, team leader
‘Montalcino is down to the producer. Some make wines that are ready to drink immediately, and some try to produce wine with ageing potential. Today we saw both, so you needed to be aware of the style.’ Tomasz Kuszneruk, Pavilion Wine
‘Tuscany was true to style, good fruit, restrained use of oak in the sub-£25 bracket. Over £30 you start to see a bit of excessive use of oak, extracted fruit, trying to be showy, which becomes unattractive. But sub-£25 the Tuscan wines had freshness, elegance. Really good, delicious wines.’ Victoria Sharples, St John Wines
‘Very good to pair with pasta dishes, poultry, salami, prosciutto, sauces with steak or grilled meat.’ Ennio Pucciarelli, Kahani London
‘You can really justify those top-end [Montalcino] prices if you’re getting ready-to-drink wines that are aged already. It’s quite rare.’ Andre Luis Martins, Cavalry & Guards Club
‘Montepulciano is little-drunk and even less understood by the UK on trade. There’s a strong need for an on-trade ambassador to extol the virtues of this style.’ Claire Love, Loves Consultancy